Sadly, the days of pool parties and beach bumming are coming to an end. The only thing getting us through is the realization that we can once more rock our statement eyeliner without the dreaded melting and smudging. Here to help us celebrate, our friends at Rank & Style used their unique algorithm to determine which eyeliner—based on the Internet’s popular opinion—lasts the longest and keeps your gaze ferocious. Want to know the winning product? Keep scrolling for the big reveal!