As drugstore beauty shoppers extraordinaire, we can always appreciate a bargain. As beauty-obsessed product junkies, we’ve also been known to splurge on a shiny compact or two. Life is all about balance, right? Thanks to our many years of product testing, we’ve figured out what to save our pennies on and what to shell out the cold hard cash (or rather, plastic) for. Scroll through to find out what beauty editors from coast to coast are willing to pay the big bucks for!