Beauty editors get a lot of products. It’s a constant struggle of wanting to try every new potion that lands on your desk and wanting to remain loyal to your latest find that’s currently giving you the dewy, glowy skin of your dreams. (Life is rough, we know.) So, not surprisingly, those must-haves change frequently. Which is why when there’s a product that shows up on editors’ product-picks lists over and over, it’s worth a look.